Shichida vs. Waldorf: A Comprehensive Comparison of Alternative Early Learning Methods

Early childhood education is pivotal in shaping a child’s cognitive, emotional, and social development. Two prominent methodologies in this field are the Shichida Method and the Waldorf Education approach. Both focus on holistic development but differ significantly in their philosophies and techniques. This article examines the key differences and similarities between these two methodologies, helping parents make informed decisions.

The Shichida Method

Children engaged in a 3D tangram puzzle activity as part of the Shichida Method, which promotes whole-brain development through hands-on, creative problem-solving exercises.

Background and Philosophy

The Shichida Method, established by Professor Makoto Shichida in 1958, is grounded in extensive research into early childhood brain development. This method prioritizes comprehensive brain training, engaging both the right and left hemispheres to enhance creativity, intuition, memory, and logical thinking. Shichida’s philosophy suggests that every child has vast potential that can be unlocked through early and appropriate stimulation and nurturing.

Type of Early Learning Method

Whole-Brain Training: The Shichida Method is categorized as a whole-brain training program that emphasizes the development of both the right and left hemispheres of the brain through structured and varied activities.

Age Range

  • Shichida Method Program: Caters to children from 6 months to 9 years old, with the intake cutoff age at 4 1/2 years old.
  • SHICHIDA at Home Program: Designed for children aged 1 to 5 years.

Key Components

  1. Right-Brain Training: Activities like flashcards, speed reading, and memory games stimulate the right hemisphere, enhancing creativity, intuition, and photographic memory.
  2. Left-Brain Training: Logical thinking and language skills are developed through fun and engaging activities such as puzzles, phonics exercises, and math games.
  3. Memory Development: Techniques like memory linking and rapid image flashing are employed to improve photographic memory and recall abilities.
  4. Emotional Development: The method emphasizes emotional bonding and positive reinforcement to build a child’s confidence and motivation.
  5. Parental Involvement: Parents are integral to the Shichida Method, participating actively in activities. During class parents also observe and learn how to create a nurturing and educational home environment.

Benefits

  • Enhanced memory and concentration.
  • Improved problem-solving skills.
  • Balanced development of both brain hemispheres.
  • Strong emotional intelligence and social skills.
  • Increased confidence and motivation.
  • Parental guidance.

Program Structure

  • Shichida Centres: Offer one class per week, ensuring fun, consistent and structured learning experiences.
  • SHICHIDA at Home: Provides a flexible online learning platform for ages 1 to 5, including videos, songs, printable workbooks, and parental guides.

 

The Waldorf Education Method

Photo by Allan Mas
Children engaging in outdoor activities as part of the Waldorf Education approach, which emphasizes a deep connection with nature to promote creativity, imagination, and holistic development.

Background and Philosophy

Waldorf Education, initiated by Rudolf Steiner in 1919, is based on Steiner’s anthroposophy, which integrates spiritual science into education. The Waldorf approach aims to develop the whole child—head, heart, and hands—through a balanced curriculum that promotes intellectual, artistic, and practical skills. The philosophy emphasizes the importance of imagination in learning and the development of free-thinking individuals.

Type of Early Learning Method

Holistic and Artistic Education: Waldorf Education is categorized as a holistic and artistic approach, focusing on the development of the whole child through imaginative play, artistic expression, and connection with nature.

Age Range

Waldorf programs typically start from preschool (around age 3) and continue through elementary and high school, covering ages 3 to 18 years.

Key Components

  1. Imaginative Play: Encourages creativity and imagination through free play and artistic activities such as drawing, painting, and storytelling.
  2. Rhythms and Routines: A consistent daily and weekly rhythm provides a secure and predictable environment for children.
  3. Nature and Outdoor Activities: Emphasizes a strong connection to nature through outdoor play, gardening, and seasonal festivals.
  4. Artistic Expression: Integrates music, dance, theatre, and visual arts into the daily curriculum to stimulate creativity and emotional expression.
  5. Delayed Academics: Formal academics are introduced gradually, allowing children to develop at their own pace without pressure.

Benefits

  • Promotes creativity and imagination.
  • Develops emotional and social intelligence.
  • Promotes a deep connection with nature.
  • Encourages independent and critical thinking.
  • Nurtures a love for artistic expression.

Program Structure

Waldorf Schools: Operate as full-time schools, offering a comprehensive curriculum from preschool through high school. Daily and weekly rhythms are central to the Waldorf approach, creating a predictable and secure learning environment.

Comparing Shichida and Waldorf

Philosophical Approach

  • Shichida: Focuses on balanced brain development and integrates emotional and social growth through structured activities and parental involvement.
  • Waldorf: Emphasizes holistic development through imaginative play, artistic expression, and a strong connection to nature, with a gradual introduction to academics.

Curriculum Structure

  • Shichida: Adaptable to the child’s pace, using various activities to stimulate different development areas, including both right and left-brain training.
  • Waldorf: Integrates artistic, practical, and academic subjects into a consistent rhythm, with a strong emphasis on imaginative play and outdoor activities.

Parental Involvement

  • Shichida: Parents are heavily involved in the learning process in class. Parents also create a supportive educational environment at home by applying lessons learned in Shichida classes.
  • Waldorf: Encourages parents to create a home environment that complements the Waldorf philosophy, focusing on rhythm, creativity, and nature.

Learning Environment

  • Shichida: Learning occurs both in centres and at home, promoting a holistic educational experience through structured activities and parental involvement.
  • Waldorf: Primarily centre-based, creating a warm, homelike classroom environment that promotes imaginative play and uses natural materials.

In-Depth Look: Core Techniques

Right-Brain Stimulation vs. Imaginative Play

  • Shichida: Utilizes flashcards with rapid image flashing and memory linking to enhance photographic memory. Techniques like deep breathing, visualization, and imaginative play stimulate creativity and intuition.
  • Waldorf: Encourages imaginative play through storytelling, role-playing, and artistic activities. Ample time for free play and creative expression promotes imaginative capacities.

Memory Development

  • Shichida: Focuses on memory training with techniques aimed at improving short-term and long-term memory, using rapid image recall, linking stories to images, and mnemonic devices.
  • Waldorf: Integrates artistic activities such as drawing, painting, and music into the curriculum, developing fine motor skills, creativity, and emotional expression.

Emotional and Social Growth

  • Shichida: Emphasizes emotional development and social skills through activities designed to build confidence, empathy, and communication skills. Parental involvement reinforces emotional bonds.
  • Waldorf: Fosters social and emotional development through cooperative play, storytelling, and group activities, emphasizing empathy, community, and respect.

Practical Applications for Parents

Shichida Method at Home

Parents can implement the Shichida Method at home through various activities that promote right-brain stimulation and emotional bonding. Parents learn in class by observation how to play educational games and activities with their children and guide them to learn key skills, while having fun together.

  • Flashcard Sessions: Regular sessions with diverse flashcards to stimulate visual memory and the whole brain connection. Also improves vocabulary and general knowledge.
  • Memory Games: Games that involve recalling sequences or the placement of images or numbers.
  • Positive Reinforcement: Using praise for effort and encouragement to build your child’s confidence and motivation.
  • Interactive Play: Pretend play and storytelling to enhance creativity and social skills.
  • Deep Breathing Exercises: Teaching relaxing deep breathing exercises to help with focus and calming down.
  • Educational Songs: Incorporating educational songs during playtime to enhance the understanding of key skills.

 

Waldorf Method at Home

Parents interested in the Waldorf approach can create a nurturing home environment that encourages imaginative play and creativity:

  • Nature Walks: Regular walks in nature to explore and appreciate the natural world.
  • Craft Activities: Engaging in simple crafts using natural materials.
  • Storytelling: Telling stories and fairy tales to stimulate imagination and language development.
  • Rhythmic Activities: Establishing daily and weekly rhythms with consistent meal times, playtimes, and rest times.
  • Artistic Expression: Providing opportunities for drawing, painting, and music to enhance creative expression and fine motor skills.

Accessibility of Programs

SHICHIDA at Home

For parents who cannot access Shichida classes in person, the Shichida Method offers an educational platform called SHICHIDA at Home. This online program provides videos, songs, printable workbooks, and parental guides to replicate the classroom experience at home.

A child engaged in a cutting activity as part of the SHICHIDA at Home program, which provides hands-on workbook exercises to develop fine motor skills and enhance learning at home.

Waldorf Online Resources

While Waldorf education is primarily centre-based, many Waldorf schools and organizations offer online resources, including e-books, webinars, and virtual classes, to support parents in creating a Waldorf-inspired home environment.

 

Conclusion

Both the Shichida and Waldorf methods offer unique and effective approaches to early childhood education, focusing on harnessing the brain’s potential during its most formative years.

  • Shichida: Ideal for parents seeking a balanced approach that includes cognitive, emotional, and social development, with significant emphasis on parental involvement and memory training.
  • Waldorf: Suited for those looking for a holistic approach that integrates imagination, nature, and artistic expression, emphasizing the development of the whole child.

Ultimately, the best choice depends on the individual needs and learning style of the child, as well as the parents’ involvement, educational philosophy and budget. By understanding the core principles and benefits of each method, parents can make a well-informed decision to support their child’s early development journey.

SHICHIDA at Home provides many activities designed to help develop your child’s cognitive abilities. Try your FREE TRIAL today!

Share This

Blog Categories

Learn more about the
SHICHIDA Method

Claim your FREE 9-page PDF. This E-book gives you an in-depth look into the SHICHIDA Method and how it can help your child.

Related Posts